Dog Food Secrets by Andrew Lewis Review (2026): Is This Homemade Dog Food Guide Worth Buying?

---

Feeding your dog well feels simple until you start reading labels. Then the questions pile up. What’s really in commercial kibble? Is homemade better? And can a downloadable guide actually teach you to cook balanced meals at home?

Dog Food Secrets by Andrew Lewis is one of the oldest and best-known digital guides that promises to answer those questions. It has been sold online for well over a decade. But a long track record doesn’t automatically make something worth your money in 2026.

This Dog Food Secrets review takes an honest, unbiased look at the guide. Based on the product materials, customer feedback, and available information, we’ll cover what’s inside, who made it, its real strengths, and its genuine limitations. We’ll also compare it to modern fresh dog food services and free recipes, so you can decide if it fits your needs.

Just so we’re clear from the start: we are not veterinarians, and we did not write this guide. Nothing here is medical advice. Always talk to your own vet before changing your dog’s diet.

Quick answer: Dog Food Secrets is an educational homemade dog food guide with recipes and background on the pet food industry. It can be a useful starting point for owners curious about home cooking. However, it is an older product, much of its general information is now available free, and — like almost all recipe collections — its meals should be checked by a veterinary professional for complete, balanced nutrition before long-term feeding.

Read the complete product details on the official website.

---

---

What Is Dog Food Secrets?

Dog Food Secrets is a digital homemade dog food guide. It is an ebook package, sold as an instant download. The core product is a main guide, now in its 4th edition, that runs to roughly 94 pages. It comes bundled with a set of bonus guides and recipe collections.

The guide has two main goals. First, it aims to educate owners about the commercial dog food industry and how to read pet food labels. Second, it provides recipes and instructions for preparing homemade dog meals in your own kitchen.

In short, it sits at the crossroads of a dog nutrition guide and a homemade dog food cookbook. It is aimed at everyday dog owners, not professionals.

It’s worth being upfront about one thing early. Some of the product’s original marketing leaned on strong, alarming claims about commercial dog food. A fair, modern review treats those claims with caution. The useful part of Dog Food Secrets is the practical, educational content — not the fear-based sales language that has surrounded it over the years.

[Related: Homemade Dog Food vs Kibble]

Who Created Dog Food Secrets?

The guide was created by Andrew Lewis. Based on the product materials, he is presented as a dog nutrition enthusiast and researcher connected to the Healthy-K9 community. According to the backstory shared in the product, Lewis began researching dog nutrition after the loss of his own dog, which he attributed to diet. That personal experience became the motivation for the guide.

It is fair to note, for EEAT and transparency, that Andrew Lewis is presented as a passionate researcher rather than a board-certified veterinary nutritionist. That distinction matters, and we’ll return to it in the limitations. It does not make the guide worthless. It simply means the recipes deserve the same professional check you would give any homemade recipe.

[Related: Best Dog Nutrition Books]

What’s Included in Dog Food Secrets?

Based on available information, the package is sold in tiered bundles (commonly described as Bronze, Silver, and Gold levels). Higher tiers add more bonus material. The exact contents and package names can change over time, so confirm the current lineup on the official page.

Digital Products

The main digital products typically include:

• The core Dog Food Secrets guide (4th edition). The main ebook. It covers the pet food industry, label reading, and the case for home cooking, plus a set of recipes.
• A collection of homemade dog food recipes. These range from full meals to treats. The 4th edition is described as adding new recipes to the original set.

Bonuses

Depending on the package tier, bonus guides have historically included items such as:

• A canine diet changeover guide — how to transition a dog from its current food to a new diet gradually.
• A homemade treats recipe collection — recipes for biscuits and snacks.
• A larger home-cooking recipe bonus with a wide range of meal ideas.
• A homemade natural soap and shampoo guide for dogs.
• A homemade canine supplement guide.
• Guides focused on puppies and dogs with special dietary needs.
• On higher tiers, a report on healthier commercial dog food brands for owners who don’t always have time to cook.

Bonus lineups vary by package and change over time. Treat the list above as illustrative, and check the official website for the current bonuses.

Member Area

Dog Food Secrets is delivered as digital downloads after purchase, through the standard ClickBank delivery process. Any member or download area, and how updates are handled, should be confirmed on the official site, since delivery details can change.

Read the complete product details on the official website.

How Dog Food Secrets Works

The guide works in three broad steps.

1. Learn the background. You read the education section about commercial dog food, ingredients, and labels.
2. Understand the approach. You learn the guide’s feeding philosophy and how to plan a balanced dog diet at home.
3. Cook and transition. You pick recipes, prepare meals, and use the changeover guide to switch your dog over slowly.

It is a self-paced, do-it-yourself system. There is no coaching, no personalization, and no ongoing support built in. What you get is information and recipes to apply on your own.

Key Features

• Downloadable, read-anywhere ebook format.
• A recipe library covering meals and healthy treats.
• Guidance on reading commercial dog food labels.
• A step-by-step dog feeding guide and diet-changeover instructions.
• Tiered packages with optional bonus guides.
• Sold through ClickBank, with its standard money-back guarantee.

Benefits

Used sensibly, a guide like this can offer real benefits:

• It gets you engaged with your dog’s diet. Many owners never think past the bag. This encourages you to.
• It demystifies labels. Learning to read an ingredient panel is a genuinely useful skill.
• It supports variety and fresh ingredients. Home cooking lets you use natural ingredients and adjust for your dog’s tastes.
• It can help picky eaters. Fresh, warm, homemade meals often appeal to dogs that snub kibble.
• It puts you in control of portions. That can help with weight management and pet obesity, which is a common problem.

These benefits are about education and engagement. They are not medical outcomes, and results will vary from dog to dog.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Beginner-friendly and easy to read.
• Encourages label awareness and dog nutrition basics.
• Includes a practical diet-changeover process.
• Recipe variety, including treats.
• One-time purchase with a money-back guarantee.

Cons

• It is an older product; parts of it feel dated.
• Much of the general information is now available free online.
• Andrew Lewis is not a board-certified veterinary nutritionist.
• Recipes are not guaranteed to be AAFCO-complete without professional review.
• The surrounding marketing has historically been alarmist about commercial food.
• No personalization or ongoing support.

Who Should Buy Dog Food Secrets

This guide may suit you if you are:

• A beginner who wants a simple, all-in-one starting point.
• An owner who likes the idea of fresh homemade dog food and wants recipe ideas in one place.
• Someone with a picky eater who wants to experiment with home cooking.
• A hands-on owner who enjoys cooking and wants to be more involved in their dog’s diet.

Who Should Avoid It

You should probably skip it, or proceed with extra care, if you are:

• Feeding a dog with a medical condition, allergies, or special needs — you need a vet-formulated plan, not a generic guide.
• Looking for a certified, guaranteed-balanced diet you can follow without any professional input.
• Comfortable researching free, reputable sources on your own.
• Expecting a done-for-you meal service rather than a DIY guide.

Dogs with existing illnesses face the greatest risk from an unbalanced homemade diet, so those owners should work directly with a veterinary professional.

How to Use the Guide

If you do buy it, here’s a sensible way to use it:

1. Read the whole guide first. Don’t jump straight to recipes.
2. Talk to your vet. Share your plan before you change anything.
3. Have recipes checked. Ask a veterinary professional, or use a veterinary-developed tool, to confirm a recipe is complete for your dog’s life stage.
4. Transition slowly. Use the changeover steps over a week or more to protect your dog’s stomach.
5. Weigh ingredients. Use a kitchen scale, and don’t swap ingredients freely — small changes can unbalance a diet.
6. Add the right supplement. Most homemade meals need a vet-recommended vitamin and mineral premix to be complete.
7. Recheck over time. Have the diet reviewed as your dog ages or its needs change.

Recipe Examples

The guide includes a range of recipes. Based on the product materials, these fall into familiar homemade categories such as:

• Protein-and-grain meals (for example, a beef or chicken base with rice and vegetables).
• Vegetable-forward meals.
• Baked biscuits and healthy treats.
• Frozen or no-cook snacks.

These are examples of the types of recipes included, described in general terms. Follow the guide’s exact measurements, and remember that a recipe looking “balanced” on the plate is not the same as being nutritionally complete on paper.

Nutritional Philosophy

The guide’s philosophy is straightforward: fresh, home-cooked meals made from recognizable ingredients, tailored to the individual dog rather than a one-size-fits-all bag. It emphasizes variety, quality proteins, and avoiding low-value fillers.

That philosophy is reasonable and shared by many fresh dog food advocates. The catch is execution. A good philosophy still has to meet the numbers. Canine nutrition depends on precise ratios of protein, fat, calcium, phosphorus, vitamins, and trace minerals — not just wholesome-sounding ingredients.

This is where honesty matters most in any Dog Food Secrets review. Independent research on homemade feeding is sobering. A 2025 Dog Aging Project study run with Texas A&M, published in the American Journal of Veterinary Research, analyzed 1,726 owner-submitted homemade recipes and found only about 6% were potentially nutritionally complete. An earlier UC Davis review of 200 recipes found roughly 95% were missing at least one nutrient, and even many recipes written by veterinarians fell short.

The takeaway is not “never cook for your dog.” It’s that any recipe collection — this one included — should be treated as a starting point that a veterinary professional or a veterinary-developed formulation tool then checks and completes. That single step is what separates a diet that might be balanced from one that is.

[Related: Best Homemade Dog Food Recipes]

Ingredients

Homemade dog meals generally build on:

• Protein: lean meats, poultry, fish, eggs.
• Carbohydrates: rice, oats, or other easily digested grains.
• Vegetables: dog-safe options like carrots, green beans, and pumpkin.
• Fats: a measured oil source for essential fatty acids.
• Supplements: a calcium source and a dog vitamin and mineral premix to close gaps.

A few safety notes that apply to all homemade feeding: never include dog-toxic foods (such as onions, garlic, grapes, raisins, chocolate, or xylitol), be cautious with dog allergies by introducing proteins one at a time, and don’t assume a human multivitamin can complete a canine diet — it can’t.

Customization by Dog Type

Homemade feeding must flex to the dog. Here’s how the guide’s general approach maps to different needs — always with veterinary input.

Senior Dogs

Homemade dog food for senior dogs often shifts toward easy-to-digest proteins and controlled calories, with joint and kidney considerations in mind. Older dogs frequently have health conditions that change their nutrient needs, so senior diets especially should be vet-reviewed.

Puppies

Homemade dog food for puppies is the highest-stakes case. Growing dogs need tightly controlled calcium-to-phosphorus ratios and higher energy. Getting this wrong can cause lasting skeletal problems. Puppy diets should be formulated or approved by a veterinary nutritionist — a generic recipe is not enough.

Large Breeds

Large and giant breeds, as puppies, are especially sensitive to calcium levels. As adults, portion control matters for joint health and weight.

Small Breeds

Small breeds need calorie-dense but carefully portioned meals, and food cut to a manageable size. They can be prone to picky eating, where fresh food sometimes helps.

Dogs With Sensitive Stomachs

For sensitive stomachs, simple recipes with a single protein and a gentle carbohydrate, introduced slowly, are the usual approach. A careful changeover matters even more here.

Comparisons

A guide is only “worth it” relative to the alternatives. Here’s how Dog Food Secrets stacks up.

Dog Food Secrets vs The Farmer’s Dog

The Farmer’s Dog is a fresh, human-grade dog food subscription. Meals are formulated by veterinary nutritionists to be complete and balanced, then pre-portioned and delivered.

• Dog Food Secrets: you cook; low cost; full control; balance is your responsibility.
• The Farmer’s Dog: they cook; higher ongoing cost; convenience and guaranteed balance.

If you want fresh food without the nutritional homework, a service like this wins on peace of mind. If you enjoy cooking and want control at low cost, the guide has a place.

Dog Food Secrets vs Ollie

Ollie is another fresh, vet-formulated delivery service, similar in spirit to The Farmer’s Dog. The same trade-off applies: Ollie offers convenience and professionally balanced meals for a recurring fee, while Dog Food Secrets offers a cheap, one-time DIY education with no balance guarantee.

Dog Food Secrets vs Commercial Dog Food

Quality commercial dog food that meets AAFCO standards is, by definition, complete and balanced, and it’s convenient. Its downsides are less control over ingredients and less freshness. Home cooking flips that: more control and freshness, but you take on the job of getting the nutrition right. Neither is automatically “better” — it depends on your dog, your time, and your willingness to do it properly.

Dog Food Secrets vs Free Recipes From Google

This is the toughest comparison for any paid guide. There are thousands of free DIY dog food recipes and natural dog food recipes online. The honest question is whether Dog Food Secrets organizes and explains things well enough to justify paying, when so much is free. For some beginners, having it in one structured place is worth it. Others will be just as well served by free, reputable veterinary sources — plus a formulation tool to check balance.

Pricing

We won’t quote a specific price, because prices and packages change and can vary by promotion. Dog Food Secrets is typically offered as a one-time purchase across a few package tiers.

Visit the official website for current pricing and available packages.

Check the latest information on the official website.

Refund Policy

Dog Food Secrets is sold through ClickBank. ClickBank’s standard policy includes a money-back guarantee (commonly 60 days) on eligible purchases. Because terms can change, confirm the current refund window and conditions at checkout before you buy.

Pros and Cons Table

Pros	Cons
Beginner-friendly, easy to read	Older product; feels dated in places
Teaches label awareness	Much info now available free
Includes diet-changeover guidance	Author is not a board-certified vet nutritionist
Recipe and treat variety	Recipes not guaranteed AAFCO-complete without review
One-time cost + money-back guarantee	Historically alarmist marketing; no personalization

Feature Comparison Table

Feature	Dog Food Secrets	Fresh Delivery (Farmer’s Dog / Ollie)	Quality Commercial Food
Format	DIY ebook guide	Cooked meals delivered	Bag or can
Cost model	One-time	Recurring subscription	Per purchase
Balance guaranteed	No (needs review)	Yes (vet-formulated)	Yes (AAFCO)
Convenience	Low (you cook)	High	High
Ingredient control	High	Low–medium	Low
Best for	Hands-on DIY owners	Convenience seekers	Everyday feeding

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is Dog Food Secrets worth buying? It can be, if you’re a beginner who wants a single, structured starting point for home cooking and you’re willing to have recipes vet-checked. If you want guaranteed balance or you’re comfortable using free sources, it may not be necessary.

2. Is Dog Food Secrets legit? Yes, it is a real product that has been sold for many years through ClickBank, with a standard money-back guarantee. “Legit” as a product does not mean every marketing claim around it is accurate, so read critically.

3. Is Dog Food Secrets a scam? Based on available information, it is a genuine digital guide with a refund policy, not a scam. The main criticism is that it’s dated and that its historical marketing overstated the dangers of commercial food.

4. Who is Andrew Lewis? He is the creator, presented as a dog nutrition researcher connected to the Healthy-K9 community. He is not described as a board-certified veterinary nutritionist.

5. What’s in the 4th edition? The 4th edition is the updated main guide (around 94 pages) with an expanded recipe set, plus bonus guides that vary by package. Check the official site for the current contents.

6. Does it include recipes? Yes. It includes meal recipes and treat recipes, with additional recipe bonuses on higher tiers.

7. Are the recipes nutritionally complete? Not guaranteed. Like most recipe collections, they should be checked against AAFCO profiles by a veterinary professional or a veterinary-developed tool before long-term feeding.

8. Is homemade dog food actually healthier than kibble? It can offer freshness and control, but “homemade” does not automatically mean “healthier.” Research shows most homemade recipes are nutritionally incomplete unless carefully formulated.

9. Can I feed this to a puppy? Only with veterinary formulation. Puppies need precise calcium and phosphorus ratios, and mistakes can cause lasting harm.

10. Can I feed this to a senior dog? Seniors often have health conditions that change their needs, so senior diets should be vet-reviewed before you start.

11. Is it good for dogs with allergies? Home cooking can help you control ingredients, but allergy diets should be guided by your vet, ideally with an elimination approach.

12. Do I still need supplements? Almost always. Most homemade meals need a vet-recommended vitamin and mineral premix and a calcium source to be complete.

13. How is it delivered? As instant digital downloads after purchase through ClickBank.

14. Is there ongoing support? No built-in coaching or personalization. It’s a self-guided product.

15. How does it compare to The Farmer’s Dog or Ollie? Those are vet-formulated fresh-delivery subscriptions offering convenience and guaranteed balance for a recurring fee. Dog Food Secrets is a cheap, one-time DIY guide without a balance guarantee.

16. Is the information available free elsewhere? Much of the general information is, yes. The value of the guide is in having it organized in one place.

17. Will it help a picky eater? It may. Fresh, warm homemade meals often appeal to dogs that refuse kibble, though results vary.

18. Can homemade food help with weight and obesity? Controlling portions and ingredients can support weight management, but do it with your vet, especially if your dog is already overweight.

19. Raw or cooked — what does it teach? The guide focuses on home-cooked meals. Raw diets carry additional food-safety considerations and should be discussed with a vet.

20. What’s the refund policy? It’s sold via ClickBank, which offers a standard money-back guarantee (commonly 60 days). Confirm current terms at checkout.

21. Is Dog Food Secrets outdated in 2026? Parts of it feel dated, and the fresh-food landscape has changed a lot. The core educational ideas still apply, but pair them with current veterinary guidance.

22. What’s the biggest risk of using it? Feeding an unbalanced diet long-term. Avoid that by having recipes professionally checked and using the right supplements.

Final Verdict

So, is Dog Food Secrets by Andrew Lewis worth buying in 2026?

Based on the product materials, customer feedback, and available information, here’s our honest, unbiased take. Dog Food Secrets is a reasonable beginner’s introduction to homemade dog food. It’s cheap, easy to read, and it does the valuable job of getting owners to think about what’s in the bowl. For a hands-on owner who enjoys cooking and wants ideas in one place, it can be a fine starting point.

But it is not a magic solution, and it shouldn’t be sold as one. It’s an older product, a lot of its general information is now free, its author is not a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, and — most importantly — its recipes need the same professional balance check as any homemade plan. The science is clear that most homemade diets fall short of complete nutrition unless they’re carefully formulated.

Our recommendation: treat Dog Food Secrets as educational material, not a prescription. Use it to learn, get curious, and start a conversation with your vet — then have any diet you actually feed reviewed for balance. Do that, and it can be a helpful piece of the puzzle. Skip that step, and no guide, this one included, is worth the risk to your dog’s health.

Learn more, and read the complete product details, on the official website.

Learn more on the official website.

---

Disclosure: This review contains affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This does not influence our assessment. This article is educational and is not veterinary or medical advice; consult your veterinarian before changing your dog’s diet.